Order from a Major Online Bookstore
Ultimate Book Price Comparison Engine
Save Your Time And Money
| AnyBook4Less.com | Order from a Major Online Bookstore |
|
| Home | Store List | FAQ | Contact Us | | ||
| Ultimate Book Price Comparison Engine Save Your Time And Money |
||
 |
Title: Russian Learner's Dictionary: 10,000 Words in Frequency Order by Nicholas J. Brown ISBN: 0-415-13792-6 Publisher: Routledge Pub. Date: July, 1996 Format: Paperback Volumes: 1 List Price(USD): $30.95 |
Average Customer Rating: 4.33 (6 reviews)
Rating: 3
Summary: Sorry, but the cons far outweight the pros
Comment: The reasoning behind the design and the need of a Frequency of Use Dictionary, that is, a dictionary which prioritises words most present in our daily conversation and use, is not an easy one to follow, whatever be the target language. By the fierce argumentation the author does in favor of the use of a Russian/English frequency dictionary - even asking for a kind of primacy in this regard - it could be imagined that we are in the threshold of something brand new and that what it is at stake is equivalent to the Inauguration of a New Age in the very important field of Lexicography, the Art of Designing and Making dictionaries, which would put the effort of Mr.Nicholas in the same level as the effort taken by world famous lexicographers as Mr.James Murray (Oxford English Dictionary), Mr.Noah (Webster), Monsieur Larousse and a few others diligent and oustanding men and women of letters. Mr.Nicholas argumentative stamina notwithstanding, and despite his undoubtfull proficiency in this very difficult subject matter, his views are not at all convincing and not at all free from the burden of proof of its real useability, and in the end what the reader has in his/her hands is a very weirdly listed dictionary or lexicon, absolutely no more useful than the traditional ones already available in the market, and most probably of less efficiency than the author thinks it has and the reader expects it to be. What is worse, it increases and stresses the need for a traditional type of lexicon.
In my opinion, the balance between pros and cons for such a type of lexicon is heavily tipped in favor of the Cons instead of the Pros:
Cons:
1- there is not enough explanation of the meaning of the Russian words listed, thus not eliminating the need or utility of a traditional lexicon. This kind of over simplification does not do any good to any one keen on learning a new language, and should not be the apanage of any dictionary. Why not more meaningfull explanations in each entry? Simplification is not a concept that should be introduced in the field of Lexicography which grows trough diversification.
2- absence of the difficult Russian cyrilic alphabet listed in its alphabetical order with corresponding sounds of vowels and consonants in English; every traditional dictionary has one for just one reason: it works and it helps the reader's life a lot. It would be a plus also here!. A good historiography of the Cyrilic would also be a handy tool, specially for the readers acquainted with its parent but narrower modern Greek alphabet. A short history of the Russian language and its Slavic and Indo-European origins would also be a bonus.
3- absence of a Russian Grammar (even a unsophisticated one would do a lot of good!!) with a due explanation of the system of declensions, present too in a synthetic language like Russian.
4- absence of list of conjugations of verbs (paradigms) in Russian, present in every good traditional lexicon.
5- lack of the important sinergy between each and every development in language and also between difficult or literary words and common ones, which means that the words beyond the 10.000 threshold do not leverage the knowledgeability of words within that limit, and vice-versa. We know by the history of the development of the languages that they evolve trough intimate contact, both external and internal. The formation of the English language is a major example of this, both from the point of view of borrowing and lending to and from Latin, French, German, Nordic languages, etc. Russian would be no exception, given the historic interchange between the slavs of early time and the Romans and, more recently, with French and German.
6- in such a dynamic world of today things change very fast, and the first 10.000 words with more frequency of use of the last 50 years will certainly not be the same in, say, 5 years. Add the communist bias present in many of the texts of the last 45 years and it will compound the problem.
7- Why 10.000 words? 3.000 would be enough. 3.000 words is the amount of words of a reasonably argumentative person. The statistics for the use of each additional 1.000 words in the frequency vocabulary, shows that the percentage points of significance fall abruptly from one bracket to another. In fact, the rationale behind such type of dictionary, if there is one, prevails more for less than for more words.
8- The final product is a bit cumbersome, phisically much bigger and difficult to handle than a traditional Lexicon. A 10.000 word traditional dictionary would weight much less with much more content and useability.
9 - Also a good add-on would be a walk trough the influence some Russian words had on our occidental culture recently, "perestroika" and "glasnot" being the most conspicuos examples. Words of more ancient penetration in our western vocabulary would be also helpfull; tovaritch (companion), mir (peace) and "bistrô" (quick) would be good to be shown.
Pros:
1 - sinergy (by proximity) between the words of more common use (see item 5 above)
2 - good examples of phrases where the use of the first 800 words is given (a good example to be followed by any dictionarist)
To sum it up, the benefits of use of a dictionary such as this is only to be completely absorved by the very serious English or American student of Russian. To the non professional readers (like myself) it serves only as a very subsidiary tool among more important ones, being the traditional dictionary still a "primus inter pares" to whom I rush whenever there is the need of researching a word.
______________________________________________________________________
Rating: 4
Summary: Extremely Useful.
Comment: I recommend this book be used with the Russian vocabulary cards by Vis-ed. Since words are listed in order of frequency of usage, you can look up the first 100, dig out those words from the set of flash cards, then move on to the next 100, etc. After the first 1000 words, you'll need to write your own cards, but Vis-ed sells blank ones too.
A useful tool, but not the screaming bargain that the author's Russian course is, this is more for the serious student.
Rating: 5
Summary: Practical Aid In Learning Russian
Comment: Having begun studying Russian earlier this year, I was very pleased to stumble upon this book. Many people study languages and in the process learn many words they may not actually need. This book literally lists the most frequently used words in order of occurance in normal conversation and writing. It is perhaps wise to note that language is a dynamic beastie and words may shuffle in frequency of use, even inviting new words into the process. But you have to start somewhere. As stated in the beginning section of this book, it is a work built upon past efforts to document usage patterns, expanded to include more than simply what you would need to pass a scholastic requirement. But remember, this is a list, not a text book. There are examples of usage offered (for the first 600 words) as well as tenses, but no detailed explanations of application. Any serious student of language will find such a reference most valuable.
 |
Title: The New Penguin Russian Course by Nicholas J. Brown ISBN: 0140120416 Publisher: Penguin USA (Paper) Pub. Date: December, 1996 List Price(USD): $17.00 |
 |
Title: Roots of the Russian Language by George Z. Patrick ISBN: 0844242675 Publisher: McGraw-Hill/Contemporary Books Pub. Date: January, 1989 List Price(USD): $16.95 |
 |
Title: First Thousand Words in Russian (Picture Word Books) by Heather Amery, Katrina Kirilenko, Stephen Cartwright ISBN: 0860207692 Publisher: E D C Publications Pub. Date: February, 1985 List Price(USD): $12.95 |
 |
Title: 501 Russian Verbs: Fully Conjugated in All the Tenses Alphabetically Arranged (501 Verbs Series) by Thomas R., Jr. Beyer ISBN: 0764113496 Publisher: Barrons Educational Series Pub. Date: 01 February, 2001 List Price(USD): $14.95 |
 |
Title: Russian Vocabulary Cards: Academic Study Card Set by Vis-Ed (Visual Education) ISBN: 1556370121 Publisher: Visual Education Assn Pub. Date: 01 October, 1997 List Price(USD): $12.95 |
Thank you for visiting www.AnyBook4Less.com and enjoy your savings!
Copyright� 2001-2021 Send your comments
